Pumpkin Swirl Sugar Cookies

  • Share on Tumblr

This best pumpkin cookie recipe includes chocolate chips and marshmallows. It’s my favorite seasonal pumpkin recipe!  This is the best pumpkin cookie recipe.

pumpkin cookie recipeMy sis-in-law has been making daily trips to the chiropractor.  Which is super duper crappy… for her.  For me, it’s been not so bad, because I volunteered to spend my afternoons with her kindergartener {Hubs calls him Happy Man} and let me tell you, he is a character.

This is the same kid who, two years ago, gave me the full on Ralphie wink-mouthclick-doublefingerguns move.  What do you say to a three year old who does this?!  {P.S. If you don’t get this reference, may I suggest watching this hysterical Christmas movie.  And getting out more.}

The first day I picked him up, we had an interesting conversation which began with this comment from the back seat, “So, how’s your brakes?”

**crickets chirping**  Ummm…

pumpkin cookie recipe

“Fine, thanks.  How are yours?”  He then regaled me with stories of changing brakes.  This kid and his dad, and my husband, changed the brakes on both families cars one day.  It was months ago, but he remembers it like it was yesterday.  “Yours were so bad, we had to take the whole wheel off!”  {replace the rotor}

The second day, we came up with words that start with the letter “J” as we drove home.  Aunt Jen.  Jellybeans.  Jumprope.  After lunch, I reminded him that pushing in his chair was a necessity, because the dog would certainly jump up on the table and eat his brownie.  And, as we all know, chocolate is poison for dogs, so we have to watch out for that.

“I’m glad I’m not a dog.  Because then I wouldn’t be able to eat chocolate.”  Hmm.  Me too, now that I think about it.  “But if I was a dog, I could run fast.”

I mean, it’s something to consider.

pumpkin cookie recipe

After lunch, Happy Man helped me whip up some pumpkin sugar cookie dough.  Here are some actual phrases spoken during this activity.  I’ll just leave it up to you to decide which of us said which phrase.

“That pumpkin looks like throw up.”
“We never pack the flour down.”
“I don’t need to wash my hands.  I licked them clean.”
“Can we taste test?”

The truly disappointing part about this was how long the dough has to chill.  You just can’t get away with an hour or two in the fridge.  It needs several hours, preferably overnight.  An eternity to a 5-year old.  I told him we could eat our cookies after school the following day.  He did not seem pleased.

pumpkin cookie recipe

Perhaps this is a good time to insert a brief note about my style.  I’m not a perfectionist AT. ALL., as my husband is so fond of reminding me.  I’m sure there is a good way to make this cookie look like a perfect spiral.  If you used smaller chocolate chips and marshmallows, it would roll easier and keep it’s shape better.  It might even look like it was out of a magazine.

I’m sure in part because I have no gift for making food look fussy and gorgeous, my recipes tend to have a quick-and-dirty kind of rough look to them.  This cookie does not look like a perfect spiral, and I like that.  There are big chunks of chocolate a marshmallow peeking out, and I like that too.  It is not my goal to use this blog to create an idyllic world that the everyday home cook has little time/patience/skill for.  This is an everyday cookie that anyone can make.  Make it as pretty or as ugly as you want.

I like them ugly.

And so does Happy Man.

printable gift tag{Get the Pumpkin Swirl Sugar Cookie gift tag here}




More pumpkin recipes you’ll love!

pumpkin krispiesPumpkin Spice Krispies pumpkin-chiffon-pie-3Pumpkin Chiffon Pie pumpkin-roll-bars-9Pumpkin Roll Bars


4.8 from 5 reviews
Pumpkin Swirl Sugar Cookies
Cook time
Total time
A pumpkin spice sugar cookie with chocolate chips and marshmallows.
Category: Cookies
Yield: 5 dozen
  • 1 cup shortening
  • 2 cups sugar
  • 3 eggs
  • 1 cup pumpkin puree
  • 1 tsp. vanilla
  • 1 tsp. salt
  • 1 tsp. baking soda
  • 1 tsp. baking powder
  • 1 tsp. cinnamon
  • ½ tsp. nutmeg
  • ½ tsp. ginger
  • 5 cups flour (+ more for rolling)
  • chocolate chips (I used bittersweet)
  • mini marhsmallows
  1. Cream shortening and sugar. Add eggs, pumpkin, and vanilla, and mix well.
  2. Add salt, soda, baking powder, and spices and mix well. Add flour and mix until combined.
  3. Wrap dough tightly in plastic and refrigerate for several hours or overnight.
  4. Divide dough into three equal sections. Place one section on a floured surface, and roll into a rectangle, about ¼" thick.
  5. Spread chocolate chips and marshmallows onto dough *(see note). Starting on a long side, roll dough into a log.
  6. Slice log into generous 1" slices, and place on a baking sheet. Bake at 350 degrees for 8-11 minutes, until the edges are lightly browned.
  7. Repeat with remaining dough sections.
I did not specify an amount for the chocolate chips or marshmallows, because you can use as much as you want. I found that it was tough to roll them and keep them together with lots of chips and marshmallows, so used around 1-2 handfuls of each. Is that exact enough?

pumpkin cookie recipe

pumpkin recipe

  • Share on Tumblr


  1. wow these look great! i was going to pin them for tonight, but was unable to :(
    thanks for sharing this great recipe!

  2. i think ugly looks pretty darn awesome this week! I would eat that ugly any day! I need to get some pumpkin and give these are try!

  3. Thanks for visiting me and commenting at OneCreativeMommy.com. I’d love it if you linked up some of your great ideas at One Creative Weekend on my site. The party is open Fridays-Wednesdays every week. Hope to see you there!

    I’m excited to check out your great site!

  4. Hey, I just wanted to let you know that I featured your post on Sugar Bee Crafts! :-)

  5. Mmmm looks delicious! Right up my alley! Mail some to me pretty please??? :)

  6. I like the one in the pictures because it looks like a smiley face! Can’t do that with a perfect spiral. What a neat idea for a cookie. And in my house the “I just licked them” quote is totally me.

  7. I’m with Happy Man – I like them ugly too! As long as they taste good, who cares how they look? Yeah, yeah, we’re food bloggers and are supposed to have beautifully stylized photos, but I figure if the food is good enough to eat, it’s good enough to photograph. Very funny post – thanks.

  8. These look scrumptious! What a neat cookie that I’ll be trying soon! Thanks so much for sharing at Mix it up Monday :)

  9. These cookies are mouth-watering, they look soooooooooooooooooooooo GOOD
    I’ve never had pumpkin cookies with marshmallow and I so wanna try

  10. thank you for sharing your delicious postsat the Thursday Favorite Things hop. xo

  11. Hi Jen,
    We would love your Pumpkin Swirl sugar Cookies, they look delicious. Enjoy your weekend and thank you so much for sharing with Full Plate Thursday.
    Come Back Soon!
    Miz Helen

  12. Lol how freaking adorable is Happy Man? And what a smart kid. I literally laughed out loud when I read “that pumpkin looks like throw-up.” My favourite line of his – hands down. The one about licking his hands clean is a very close second. These cookies look beautiful – I’m with you, I’m not a perfectionist either. I could polish off a dozen of these and like Happy Man, would’ve found it hard to wait a whole day too before eating them!

  13. Challenging little kid… the cookies are great and so terrifically seasonal. Thanks for sharing them on foodie friday.

  14. Yum! These look delicious. I love anything Pumpkin. Thanks so much for linking up to Creative Thursday. Can’t wait to see what you share this week! Have a wonderful week.

  15. Dear Jen, these cookies look positively delightful! I just came by from the Gooseberry Patch! You have a beautiful blog…and aside from the delicious recipes, I also love this script font…very pretty touch. Please do visit soon. Blessings, Catherine

  16. Omg, I found your blog in the begining of the week then I somehow lost it, I was so happy when I saw you featured on Something Swanky, these look so delicious!

  17. Holly Morales says:

    These look amazing! I LOVE sugar cookies and pumpkin…and baking…and could probably go on. Just found your page and I just know I’ll be pinning recipes like crazy. Thank you for the cute story. I love reading little back stories to recipes and projects. :o)

  18. Hi! I tried these cookies and blogged about it! They looked so good, but I don’t think mine turned out right. I did do some minor tweaking here and there, but what do you think? Did I do something wrong? http://jessica-healthymommyhealthybaby.blogspot.com/2012/10/sweet-saturday-26-pumpkin-smores-cookies.html. Would love to hear your thoughts! thanks so much for the inspiration! Your site is great!

  19. These sound wonderful. I’m surprised that the marshmallows don’t melt into nothingness. Being the basically lazy person that I am, I think I’d just mix in the marshmallows and chocolate chips and call it a day. The whole refrigeration and rolling it out part doesn’t do it for me.


  1. […] when, in another recent pumpkin post, I told a story about my nephew trying to decide whether or not he should be a dog?  This one […]

  2. […] creations!! Butterscotch Pecan Ice Cream by Life Made Simple Pumpkin Swirl Sugar Cookies by Jen’s Favorite Cookies Chocolate Hazelnut Icebox Cake by Flour Me with Love Ghost Topped Pumpkin Cheesecakes with […]

  3. […] sugar cookies.  And chocolate sugar cookies.  And oatmeal cut-out cookies.  And more recently, pumpkin sugar cookies.  I had this brilliant idea to make peanut butter sugar cookies with chocolate frosting to […]

  4. […] Pumpkin Swirl Sugar Cookies with help from Happy Man. […]

  5. […] Chocolate Crinkles 12: Chocolate Gingersnaps 13: Soft Sugar Cookies 14:  Pumpkin Swirl Cookies 15:  Coconut Cream Cookies 16: Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies 17: Giant Ginger Cookies 18: […]

  6. […] on to #4, this Coconut Ginger Granola was a big hit. The Pumpkin Swirl Sugar Cookies came in at #3. This crazy easy Chocolate Peppermint Fudge found it’s way on to Huffington […]

  7. […] Ginger Cream (Spabettie) 8. Gingersnap Pumpkin Spice Sandwich Cookies (Simply Southern Baking) 9. Pumpkin Swirl Sugar Cookies (Jen’s Favorite […]

  8. […] kid.  I still think about the week he spent his afternoons with me a couple years ago.  He asked me about my brakes.  What 5-year old does […]

  9. […] I forged ahead.  One of my early successes was these Pumpkin Swirl Cookies.  They were mighty tasty, and I rode the high from that win for quite a […]

  10. […] from Two Twenty One Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Oatmeal Bars from Sally’s Baking Addiction Pumpkin Swirl Sugar Cookies from Jen’s Favorite Cookies Chocolate Chip Pumpkin Granola Bars from In Katrina’s […]

  11. […] made pumpkin cookies last October, too, but I ask you, why should pumpkin be relegated to fall?  Shouldn’t truly […]

  12. […] 4. Delicious Pumpkin Seeds Slap Dash Mom 5. Pumpkin Streusel Muffins Poet in the Pantry 6. Pumpkin Swirl Sugar Cookies Jen’s Favorite Cookies 7. White Chocolate Chip Pumpkin Cookies Alida’s Kitchen 8. […]

join the conversation


Rate this recipe: